Back to newsroom
News

Too big to be small: how to scale a business without losing control

In news by Business School Netherlands

A business begins to lose control when its growth creates more complexity than its current way of managing can handle.

The signs are not always dramatic. Decisions take a little longer. More meetings are added. Responsibilities become less clear. The founder becomes busier, yet has less time to think about the future. Customers may still be buying and revenue may still be growing, but the organisation is becoming harder to run.

Prof Bernie van Zijl explored these issues in a series of BSN’s Read∞ sessions on Jason Goldberg’s The Art of Scale: Mastering the Craft of Growth. Goldberg’s central argument is that a business cannot continue to rely on the same informal, founder-led methods at every stage of its development. As the organisation grows, it must change how decisions are made, how work is coordinated and how responsibility is distributed.

Growth and scale are not the same thing

Growth generally means that the business is doing more. It may be serving more customers, employing more people, entering new markets or generating more revenue.

Scale is about building the organisational capacity to handle that growth without allowing cost, confusion and dependence on a few individuals to increase at the same rate.

A growing business may add five employees because everyone is overloaded. A scaling business first asks why the work is creating so much pressure. It may need more people, but it may also need clearer processes, better technology, more focused priorities or a different division of responsibility.

Growth can therefore happen without scale. Rapid growth may even conceal structural problems for a time. Strong demand and rising revenue can make the business model appear healthy while the organisation behind it becomes increasingly fragile.

When a business becomes too big to be small

Goldberg uses entrepreneur and author Doug Tatum’s idea of “No Man’s Land” to describe the point at which a business is too big to be small and too small to be big.

In the early stages, the founder is often the organisation’s informal management system. The founder knows the customers, approves expenditure, solves operational problems, checks quality, recruits employees and makes most of the important decisions. This can work well while the team is small and communication is direct.

As the business grows, the same arrangement starts to slow it down. More employees create more conversations, handovers, dependencies and opportunities for misunderstanding. Decisions queue up with the founder. Managers hesitate because they are uncertain about their authority. Problems are escalated upwards instead of being resolved where they occur.

The founder may respond by working longer hours and becoming more involved. That can provide temporary relief, but it often reinforces the organisation’s dependence on one person.

Seven signs that the existing management approach has reached its limit

Drawing on the issues raised in the Read∞ session, the following signs can help leaders assess whether the organisation’s current management approach has reached its limit. This is a BSN editorial diagnostic rather than a seven-part model from Goldberg’s book.

  1. Routine decisions repeatedly return to the founder or senior leader. Employees may have job titles and areas of responsibility, but still seek approval before acting.
  2. Information travels through individuals rather than reliable systems. People depend on conversations, messages and memory to know what is happening.
  3. Roles have become blurred. Several people may believe they own the same task, while other responsibilities are overlooked.
  4. Meetings are increasing without improving coordination. More time is spent discussing work, but decisions, owners and next steps remain unclear.
  5. Quality depends on who does the work. Customers receive different experiences because important processes are not consistently followed.
  6. Managers spend too much time managing upwards. Instead of leading teams and improving performance, they prepare updates, seek permission and wait for decisions.
  7. Senior leaders have little time for strategy. Their days are consumed by operational matters that should increasingly be handled elsewhere.

None of these signs necessarily means that the business is failing. They indicate that the way it is managed has not kept pace with its size.

Why complexity grows so quickly

Goldberg uses a simple network illustration to show why coordination becomes more demanding as people are added. A group of 10 people has 45 possible one-to-one communication links. At 50 people, the number rises to 1,225.

Not every employee will communicate directly with every other employee. The calculation is useful because it shows that coordination does not increase in a straight line.

As complexity increases:

  • decisions can take longer;
  • information may become distorted as it moves;
  • teams can lose sight of the organisation’s main priorities;
  • work may be duplicated;
  • customers may be passed between departments;
  • costs may rise without a matching improvement in output;
  • responsibility can become harder to locate.

This is why adding people does not always create additional capacity. Without clearer structures and systems, it can create more work for everyone.

Competition, complexity and size

In Goldberg’s framework, the first three laws that explain why businesses struggle to scale are the laws of competition, complexity and size.

The first pressure is competition. A profitable market attracts attention. Competitors may copy an offer, lower their prices, recruit key employees or introduce an alternative that is easier for customers to use. A growing business therefore needs a clear reason for customers to continue choosing it.

The second pressure is complexity. More products, employees, locations, customers and systems create more possible points of failure. Complexity can weaken speed and focus, which may have been among the organisation’s original strengths.

The third pressure is size. As the organisation grows, employees are further removed from the founder and from one another. Without deliberate attention, the business can lose the sense of connection, care and shared responsibility that characterised its earlier years.

Growth therefore creates a difficult tension. The business needs greater structure, but it must not allow structure to become unnecessary bureaucracy. It needs more specialised roles, but it must not create silos. It needs leaders to delegate, but delegation must be supported by clear expectations and reliable information.

Retreat, retool or resist

Goldberg presents three broad responses when an organisation reaches this point: retreat, retool or resist.

Retreat
The first option is to limit growth intentionally. There is nothing inherently wrong with choosing to remain a small business. A smaller organisation can be profitable, focused and closely connected to its customers. The important point is that this should be a conscious strategic decision rather than the result of exhaustion or unmanaged problems.

Resist
The second option is to continue growing while holding on to the existing way of working. Leaders keep making most of the decisions. Processes remain informal. Responsibilities are adjusted as problems arise. Additional employees are recruited, but the underlying causes of pressure are not addressed. This may work for a while, particularly when demand is strong. Eventually, however, the organisation becomes too dependent on individual effort and intervention.

Retool
The third option is to redesign the business for its next stage. Retooling does not mean replacing everything that made the organisation successful. It means identifying which early practices remain useful and which have become constraints. This is usually the most demanding option because it requires leaders to change their own behaviour as well as the organisation’s systems.

A practical retooling agenda

A practical retooling agenda can be organised around six areas. This structure is a BSN application of the issues discussed in the session, not a six-step Goldberg framework.

1. Sharpen the strategy
Growth by opportunity can lead a business into too many products, markets and customer groups. Leaders need to be clear about where the organisation will compete, what it will be known for and which opportunities it will decline. A strategy is not only a list of things the business plans to do. It also defines what the business will not do.

    2. Clarify decision-making authority
    Employees need to know which decisions they can make independently, which decisions require consultation and which must be escalated. Delegation without boundaries creates risk. Boundaries without delegation create delay.

    3. Define roles around outcomes
    A job description may list activities, but accountability should also make the intended result clear. For example, “manage customer queries” describes an activity. “Ensure customer queries receive an accurate response within one working day” provides a clearer outcome against which performance can be discussed.

    4. Build repeatable processes
    Not every task requires a formal manual. Work that is important, frequent or vulnerable to error should not depend entirely on memory. Useful processes make good practice easier to repeat. They should explain the essential steps, the responsible person, the standard to be met and how exceptions are handled.

    5. Create a management rhythm
    Growing organisations need regular opportunities to review priorities, performance and obstacles. This does not mean filling calendars with meetings. A useful management rhythm reduces the need for unnecessary meetings by creating predictable forums for specific decisions.

    6. Develop management capacity
    A founder cannot delegate responsibility to people who have not been given the authority, information or skills to carry it. Managers need clear expectations, access to reliable information and the confidence to make decisions. They also need to understand when a matter genuinely requires escalation.

    Scaling in an emerging-market context

    The Read∞ discussion also placed Goldberg’s ideas in an emerging-market context. Participants considered how limited access to finance, inadequate business records, regulation and uneven access to technology can make the transition to scale more difficult.

    Resourcefulness and entrepreneurial energy are valuable in these environments. They help businesses respond quickly, operate with limited resources and recognise opportunities that larger organisations may overlook.

    The difficulty comes when constant improvisation becomes the normal way of managing. A business cannot build predictable performance if every day requires a new workaround. The transition from entrepreneurial hustle to organisational discipline does not mean losing flexibility. It means creating a more stable foundation from which the business can respond effectively.

    Context matters. The right approach to scale will not look identical in every market or industry. The underlying question remains the same: can the organisation handle more activity without becoming proportionately more fragile?

    We have a lot of information, data and knowledge floating around, but it means nothing if you do not relate it to your context.
    – Prof Bernie van Zijl, BSN Read∞

    A BSN scale-readiness check

    The following reflection questions translate the session’s ideas into a practical organisational discussion:

    • Which decisions still depend unnecessarily on one person?
    • Where has adding people created more coordination rather than more capacity?
    • Which important activities are handled differently each time?
    • Which roles or responsibilities are currently unclear?
    • Where are customers experiencing the effects of internal complexity?
    • Which parts of the business cannot function properly when a particular person is absent?
    • What should the leadership team stop doing to create room for the next stage?

    The answers will usually point towards a small number of structural issues. These may involve strategy, leadership, talent, processes, technology or financial management. The task is not to solve everything at once. It is to identify which constraint is most likely to prevent the organisation from moving forward.

    Scaling requires a management transition

    Scaling is often discussed as a question of sales, funding or market expansion. These matter, but they are only part of the picture. A business also needs to change how it is led and managed.

    The organisation must gradually become less dependent on the founder’s personal involvement and more capable of producing sound decisions, consistent work and reliable information across teams.

    That transition can feel uncomfortable. Leaders may worry that delegation will weaken standards or that processes will slow people down. Poorly designed delegation and unnecessary processes can do exactly that. The purpose of retooling is not to make a growing business behave like a large corporation. It is to preserve its strengths while building the capacity required for its next stage.

    Working through a growth challenge in your own organisation?

    BSN’s Global Action Learning MBA connects management theory with practical organisational challenges. Students apply what they learn through Action Learning projects carried out in their own work environments.

    About this article

    This article is based on a BSN Read∞ discussion led by Prof Bernie van Zijl on Jason Goldberg’s The art of Scale: Mastering the Craft of Growth. It interprets selected ideas for a wider management audience. Practical examples, reflection questions and implementation checklists are BSN editorial applications unless otherwise stated.

    Sources and further reading

    Business School Netherlands

    Newsletter

    Subscribe to our newsletter

    Enter your details to receive our monthly newsletter with news, blog articles and publications.

    "*" indicates required fields

    This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.