A strategy becomes useful only when it changes what people do.
Many organisations have detailed plans, capable employees and ambitious goals. Yet day-to-day work continues much as it did before the strategy was agreed. The problem is not always the quality of the strategy. It is often the absence of a reliable system for turning strategic choices into priorities, responsibilities, measures and regular action.
This challenge becomes more serious as an organisation grows. More teams are involved, information travels further and employees face competing demands. Without a shared method of execution, each department may work hard while the organisation as a whole makes limited progress.
“So many times, we have good strategies on paper, but we fall short in applying them.”
– Prof Bernie van Zijl, BSN Read∞
Why good strategies fail during implementation
Strategies often fail quietly. There may be no single disastrous decision. Instead, the organisation becomes absorbed by immediate operational demands. Customer queries, staff matters, supplier problems, deadlines and unexpected events consume the available time.
Goldberg’s execution discussion incorporates ideas associated with Chris McChesney, Sean Covey and Jim Huling’s The 4 Disciplines of Execution. These include the operational “whirlwind”, Wildly Important Goals, lead measures, a visible scoreboard and a regular cadence of accountability.
The whirlwind contains the work required to keep the organisation functioning. It cannot simply be ignored. Customers still need support, salaries must be paid and operational problems must be resolved. The difficulty is that this work can absorb all available capacity.
An execution system must therefore help teams make progress on strategically important work while continuing to manage day-to-day operations.
Start with a small number of priorities
An organisation cannot treat every goal as equally important. When leaders announce a long list of priorities, employees must either divide their attention across all of them or decide for themselves which ones matter most. In practice, immediate operational demands usually win.
Focus requires choice. A useful strategic priority should:
- make a meaningful difference to the organisation;
- support the chosen strategic direction;
- respond to a genuine opportunity or constraint;
- be specific enough to guide decisions;
- have a defined owner;
- be achievable within a realistic period.
The number of priorities should be small enough for teams to understand what requires special attention alongside their normal operational work. This does not mean that other work is unimportant. It means that the organisation is distinguishing between the work that maintains current performance and the work that changes future performance.
Choose the moves that can change the business.
In The Art of Scale, Goldberg uses the term “winning moves” for strategic choices that can materially change the organisation’s position. A winning move is more than an improvement target. It may involve entering a new market, developing a repeatable revenue model, improving a critical capability or changing how the organisation creates value.
A practical way to test a proposed move is to ask:
- Will this change the organisation’s prospects in a meaningful way?
- Does it use our genuine strengths?
- Does it respond to relevant market or operating conditions?
- Can we explain why it matters now?
- Can the organisation realistically execute it?
- What will we stop or reduce to make capacity available?
The final question is often overlooked. New priorities are regularly added without removing existing commitments. A strategy that assumes unlimited capacity is not a workable strategy.
Connect long-term ambition to shorter-term action
Long-term goals can provide direction, but they are too distant to guide weekly decisions on their own. The organisation needs a clear line connecting its ambition to the work being done now.
Goldberg connects the execution plan to what Jim Collins and Jerry Porras call a BHAG: a Big Hairy Audacious Goal. He then links the longer-term goal to winning moves, Wildly Important Goals and Objectives and Key Results.
The following structure is a BSN editorial way of making that connection visible:
- Strategic direction – Where is the organisation going, and how does it intend to compete or create value?
- Key strategic moves – Which changes are most important to reaching that direction?
- Annual or quarterly priorities – What must be achieved during the current period?
- Team objectives – What does each team need to contribute?
- Measures – How will the team know whether its work is producing progress?
- Weekly commitments – What will be completed before the next review?
Different organisations use different names for these levels. The terminology matters less than the connection between them. Employees should be able to explain how their current work contributes to a team objective, how that objective supports an organisational priority and how that priority advances the strategy.
Translate shared priorities into clear accountability
Execution weakens when a priority belongs to everyone. Shared contribution is important, but each result still needs an identifiable owner. This person does not have to perform all the work. The owner is responsible for coordinating action, monitoring progress and ensuring that decisions are made.
For each priority, clarify:
- the intended result;
- the responsible owner;
- the contributing teams;
- the deadline or review period;
- the available resources;
- the measures that will be tracked;
- the decisions the owner may make;
- the circumstances that require escalation.
This prevents a familiar meeting outcome: everyone agrees that something is important, but no one leaves with clear responsibility for moving it forward. Accountability should also be matched with authority. It is unreasonable to hold someone responsible for an outcome while requiring senior approval for every meaningful decision.
Measure the actions that influence the result
Many organisations monitor final outcomes such as revenue, profit, customer retention, employee turnover or delivery performance. These are useful, but they are generally lag measures: they confirm what has already happened.
The 4 Disciplines of Execution distinguishes these from lead measures: activities or conditions that can be influenced before the final result is known. The following examples illustrate how a final result might be connected to an activity a team can influence. They are BSN editorial examples, not a table reproduced from Goldberg or 4DX.
Desired Result
Possible lead measure
- Increase sales revenue
- Improve customer retention
- Reduce delivery delays
- Improve service quality
- Strengthen recruitment
- Improve cash collection
- Number of qualified sales conversations completed
- Percentage of at-risk customers contacted within agreed period
- Percentage of projects completing each planning stage on time
- Percentage of cases resolved correctly at first contact
- Number of suitable candidates in the active pipeline
- Percentage of invoices followed up before becoming overdue
A lead measure should not be selected simply because it is easy to count. It must have a credible relationship with the desired result and be something the team can influence.
Measures can also create unintended behaviour. A sales team assessed only on the number of calls made may increase activity without improving the quality of conversations. A customer-service team assessed only on speed may close cases before problems are fully resolved. Leaders should therefore ask not only whether a number is improving, but whether it is encouraging the intended behaviour.
Give the team a useful scoreboard
People find it difficult to act on information they cannot see. A simple scoreboard makes progress visible and gives teams a shared reference point. It helps employees understand whether their current actions are moving the priority forward.
An effective scoreboard should be:
- easy to understand;
- limited to the most relevant measures;
- updated regularly;
- visible to the people responsible for the work;
- clear about the current position and intended target;
- connected to decisions and action.
A complicated dashboard containing dozens of indicators may provide information without creating focus. The purpose of a scoreboard is not to decorate a reporting pack. It is to help a team decide what to do next.
Create a rhythm of commitment and accountability
A strategy is unlikely to survive on quarterly presentations alone. Teams need a regular forum in which they review progress, discuss obstacles and make new commitments. This reflects the 4DX idea of a cadence of accountability and Goldberg’s emphasis on regular commitment rhythms.
A short weekly execution meeting might address four practical questions:
- What did we commit to completing?
- What progress do the measures show?
- What is preventing further progress?
- What will each responsible person complete next?
These questions are a BSN editorial meeting structure. The discussion should remain focused on the selected strategic priority and the commitments required to advance it. Operational issues should be handled elsewhere unless they directly prevent progress.
The value of the rhythm comes from consistency. When execution meetings are repeatedly cancelled because something more urgent has appeared, the organisation sends a clear message about the true importance of the strategy. Accountability meetings should not become occasions for public blame. Their purpose is to make progress visible, address obstacles early and reinforce ownership.
Systemise what repeatedly works
As organisations grow, successful execution must become repeatable. A capable employee may have developed an effective way to onboard customers, assess suppliers, prepare proposals or manage projects. When that knowledge remains in one person’s head, the organisation cannot use it consistently.
Goldberg’s execution discussion ends with systemisation: identifying important systems, prioritising urgent needs, assigning owners, documenting standard processes, training employees and maintaining regular improvement.
A practical version of that work is to:
- Identify the activities that matter most.
- Prioritise processes that create risk, delay or inconsistency.
- Assign an owner to each process.
- Document the essential steps and standards.
- Train the people involved.
- Monitor whether the process produces the intended result.
- Improve it as circumstances change.
The purpose is not to prescribe every action. Employees still need judgement, particularly when circumstances fall outside the normal process. A useful system handles routine work reliably so that people can apply their judgement where it is genuinely needed.
Systems should reduce friction, not create it
Employees often resist systems because their experience of systems is associated with unnecessary forms, approvals and reporting. That resistance may be justified. A poor system adds work without improving the result. A useful system reduces uncertainty, prevents repetition and makes it easier for employees to complete work correctly.
Before introducing a new process, leaders can ask:
- Which problem is this process solving?
- Who will use it?
- What information is genuinely required?
- Which step could be removed?
- Can technology handle part of the work?
- What decision will the information support?
- How will we know whether the process is helping?
Systemisation is not the same as bureaucracy. Bureaucracy exists when maintaining the process becomes more important than achieving the outcome.
A 30-day strategy execution experiment
The ideas discussed in the Read∞ session can be translated into a simple 30-day experiment. This is a BSN editorial application rather than a 30-day programme set out in Goldberg’s book.
Week 1: Select the priority
Choose one strategically important result that requires coordinated action. Define the current position, the intended result and why it matters.
Week 2: Clarify contributions and measures
Identify the accountable owner and contributing teams. Select a small set of lag and lead measures that will provide useful evidence of progress.
Week 3: Introduce the scoreboard and review meeting
Create a simple shared scoreboard. Hold the first weekly execution meeting and agree on specific commitments for the following week.
Week 4: Remove one recurring point of friction
Identify a process, approval or information gap that is slowing progress. Test a practical improvement and assess its effect.
At the end of the 30 days, review what has been learned:
- Is the priority still the right one?
- Are the measures useful?
- Are people making clear commitments?
- Is the meeting helping the team make decisions?
- Which obstacle requires leadership attention?
- Which practice should become part of the regular operating rhythm?
Execution is also a learning process
From an Action Learning perspective, execution creates evidence that leaders can use to test assumptions and adjust their approach. Even a well-considered strategy contains assumptions about customers, employees, competitors, technology, costs and the organisation’s ability to change.
Action produces evidence. Evidence supports reflection. Reflection can lead to adjustment. A team may learn that a selected lead measure does not influence the result as expected. A new process may create an unanticipated delay. A customer response may challenge an important strategic assumption.
The organisation needs enough discipline to remain focused and enough openness to change course when the evidence supports it.
Strategy becomes real through repeated action
The difference between an organisation that discusses strategy and one that executes it is rarely a single tool or framework. It is the repeated practice of choosing what matters most, making responsibility clear, tracking measures that support decisions, reviewing progress regularly, dealing with obstacles early, documenting useful practices and learning from action.
This may sound less dramatic than the original strategic vision. It is also where that vision either becomes real or remains a presentation. A strategy provides direction. An execution system helps the organisation move.
A strategy needs to work in the organisation, not only on paper.
BSN’s Action Learning approach connects learning with real organisational issues. Through the Global Action Learning MBA and tailor-made in-company programmes, participants and teams work on practical challenges within their own work environments.
About this article

This article is based on a BSN Read∞ discussion led by Prof Bernie van Zijl on Jason Goldberg’s The Art of Scale: Mastering the Craft of Growth. It interprets selected ideas for a wider management audience. Practical examples, reflection questions and implementation checklists are BSN editorial applications unless otherwise stated.
Sources and further reading
- Jason Goldberg, The Art of Scale: Mastering the Craft of Growth.
- Chris McChesney, Sean Covey and Jim Huling, The 4 Disciplines of Execution: Achieving Your Wildly Important Goals.
- Jim Collins and Jerry I. Porras, Built to Last: Successful Habits of Visionary Companies.
- Business School Netherlands, BSN Read∞: The Art of Scale – Session 3, The Art of Execution